The Archive
Every debate we've published, sortable by newest, most voted, or most discussed.
sport
The US Senate has voted 77-22 to give the NCAA an antitrust exemption and limit college athletes' pay and transfers. Stability for college sport, or a raw deal for players?
celebrity
Madonna, 68, won seven VMAs in her first performance there in 23 years, then faced online criticism of her age and image. Fair critique of a performance, or ageism?
Always Open
A new survey says 74% of US knowledge workers do some work on a typical Sunday. A smart head start on a calmer Monday, or should weekends be strictly off-limits?
culture
The UK government says entry to England's national museums will stay free for everyone, tourists included. The right call, or should overseas visitors have to pay?
politics
The White House is running taxpayer-funded TV ads starring Trump during NFL games, weeks before the midterms. Patriotic public messaging, or political propaganda?
technology
X is still refusing adverts for Musk, a critical new documentary about the platform's own owner. A private company's right, or an abuse of its power?
Always Open
Singapore can now fine bus passengers up to S$500 for playing audio out loud. Should the UK start fining people who play music or videos without headphones?
celebrity
The BBC has cut a Katherine Ryan joke about Victoria Beckham from Have I Got News For You after two viewers complained. Right call, or too thin-skinned?
sport
A USC linebacker was ejected for a targeting hit that sent Oregon QB Dante Moore to hospital, but new rules mean no automatic ban. Should a first targeting foul cost a game?
culture
Greece's prime minister has rejected borrowing parts of its own monument from the British Museum. Should the Parthenon Marbles return to Athens for good?
Always Open
In a US survey, 76% of Gen Z who fronted money for a group expense say they weren't fully repaid. If a friend owes you a fiver, do you chase it or let it go?
technology
Revolut is trialling facial recognition payments in London cafés, so customers pay just by looking at the till. Handy upgrade, or a risk to your biometric data?
politics
The Trump administration is moving to cancel $810m of Congress-approved spending five days before the financial year ends. Fair cost-cutting, or an end-run around Congress?
world
Iran has offered to reopen the Strait of Hormuz within seven days if the US lifts its blockade and oil sanctions. Should Washington take the deal?
1 vote
Always Open
A government consultation on letting couples in England and Wales legally marry almost anywhere closed this week. Should the rules on wedding venues be scrapped?
1 vote
celebrity
Kim Kardashian's new reality show follows the parents of teenage players at an elite Arizona baseball academy. Fair game for TV, or a step too far for youth sport?
culture
Taylor Swift's new Encore edition adds four songs to an album already sold in dozens of versions. Savvy business for superfans, or unfair pressure to buy again?
sport
Prime Minister Andy Burnham says the 1985 ban on drinking alcohol in sight of the pitch at football matches could go. Should fans be allowed a pint in their seats?
politics
Mayor Zohran Mamdani hosted Trump at Gracie Mansion to talk federal housing money for New York. Smart pragmatism, or normalising a president he's called a fascist?
1 vote
world
Britain will refuel Saudi jets defending against Houthi missiles and drones. Standing by an ally and a vital trade route, or a step back into Yemen's war?
2 votes
Always Open
A new Kinsey Institute survey finds 39% of US singles have used AI in their dating lives. Harmless help finding the right words, or misleading your match?
2 votes
technology
Amazon has blocked Meta's new AI shopping agent, Muse, from buying on Amazon.com. Protecting customers' accounts, or shutting out an assistant shoppers chose?
1 vote
politics
Reps. Massie and Khanna say the DOJ is still withholding over 3 million Epstein files, and they're two signatures from forcing a vote. Right to push, or midterm theater?
1 vote
world
Britain has sanctioned Israeli settlement leaders, and Trump says he didn't know. A defensible break from Washington's line, or a president caught flat-footed?
1 vote