We'll email you a one-click sign-in link. No password needed.
One story. Every side.
← Back to all takes
culture

Alex Gibney's documentary "Musk" premiered at Venice to strong reviews, and Elon Musk calls it a "boring hit piece". Serious accountability journalism, or a one-sided takedown?

Alex Gibney's documentary "Musk" premiered at Venice to strong reviews, and Elon Musk calls it a "boring hit piece". Serious accountability journalism, or a one-sided takedown?

Musk's lawyer has sent legal letters over its claims. Gibney, an Oscar-winning documentarian, interviewed Musk's father, first wife, an ex-girlfriend and former colleagues for the film.

What happened

Alex Gibney's documentary Musk, featuring interviews with Musk's father, his first wife, an ex-girlfriend and former colleagues, premiered at the Venice Film Festival to positive reviews and a lengthy standing ovation. Musk responded on X calling the film a hit piece, attacking Gibney's integrity, and his attorney has reportedly sent a letter to the production company disputing a claim about Musk's use of Starlink around the 2024 election.

Why people disagree

Backers of the film point to Gibney's Oscar-winning track record and NPR's reporting that it obtained and authenticated text messages central to the film's claims, arguing this is substantiated journalism about a uniquely powerful private figure. Musk and his defenders argue the film's cast, described by Musk as people who have an axe to grind, was assembled to build a predetermined negative narrative rather than a fair one.

What's still unclear

Whether Musk's legal team follows through with an actual lawsuit, and what that would mean for the film's scheduled October US theatrical release.

More takes